Mutual funds are a diversified group of stocks, bonds or money market securities that create returns from more than one source. Because of their diversification, the risk involved is reduced or limited.Investors who want to limit or reduce their risk usually opt for mutual funds. Mutual fund ratings are used to aid smart investors rank which funds are best for them, based on the amount of risk that is involved. Different companies determine the fund rating based on their own criteria.
MorningstarSince 1985, Morningstar has been one of the premier mutual fund rating services. By assigning a rating of one to five stars, they have guided investors who have been looking for an edge for over 2 decades now. Starting with the company’s risk score, the fund’s 5 year return is then subtracted, resulting in a risk adjusted rating score. Of course, the problem is that the rating is highly biased to past performance and does not accurately reflect the current risk of the company. So while Morningstar is good at helping you determine which funds have a good track record, it doesn’t help to determine which funds will do well in the future.
Lipper, Inc.This company has been analyzing funds and helping investors select the best mutual funds for them since 1971. Lipper ranks funds based on performance risk, but is based on poor or risky performance meaning that the higher the risk, the higher the rating. The lower the risk, the less chance the investor has of losing money. Lipper has a five point rating system that includes five different criteria (total return, consistent return, preservation, tax efficiency and expense) to help determine the actual risk of a fund.
Business WeekTheir Mutual Fund Scoreboard is carried annually in their magazine, but savvy investors can access that scoreboard at any time by going to Business Week’s website and accessing the Mutual Fund Scoreboard, which is updated monthly. They rate funds on quite a few different criteria, but they obtain the overall rating by assessing the performance over a five year period, based on risk adjusted returns. They deliver the ratings in a letter grade with A being superior and F being very poor.
Schwab Mutual Fund OneSource Select ListSchwab’s experts have created a list of pre-screened, no load, no transaction fee funds. This list is updated quarterly and utilizes a list of strict criteria to arrive at the ratings. These criteria include a minimum three year performance track record and have a minimum of $40 million in assets (in most cases). The funds that make the list are rated on risk, performance, diversification and other factors.
The wise investor will not rely on only one rating system, but, in fact, several in order to obtain a clear picture of a mutual fund’s risk factor. While past performance of a fund may shed a little light on the fund’s risk factor and viability, future performance can not be predicted based solely on this criteria. A complete picture of the company and the fund must be obtained in order to fully assess the potential risks and strength of the fund. Even then it is not an exact science and there are no guarantees.